I just finished making tags for my Etsy store and I am very happy with them. I had a custom stamp made at rubberstamps.net. It came out really nicely. I did the tags on a heavy watercolor paper with an embossing stamp kit. I also made put a metal eyelet with a little grommet machine and some nice pink ribbon, both items found in the garment district for cheap. I think next time I’ll try out some different colors and paper.